If you feel like a human pacifier, just like the mom who wrote to us below, you’re not alone. Many breastfeeding moms experience this phase, where their baby doesn’t just nurse for nourishment but also for comfort, soothing, and sleep. While this is entirely natural—especially in the first four months when a baby’s sucking reflex is strong—it can also be exhausting.
Not all babies accept traditional pacifiers, and some strongly prefer the warmth and security of nursing to fall asleep. But the good news? This phase doesn’t last forever, and there are strategies to gently (or quickly) break the habit when you’re ready.
Below, we’ll explain two methods: one designed for a quicker transition and one that allows for a gentler, more gradual shift.
Mom’s Question:
How can I stop my baby from using my breast as a pacifier to fall asleep? I breastfeed and formula feed. Please do not just say try a pacifier because I do, and he has a hard time putting and keeping it in his mouth.Thank you, Heidi
Breaking the Feeding-Sleep Association: Why It Matters
One of the main reasons babies nurse for comfort is because they have developed a feeding-sleep association. This means they rely on suckling—not just to satisfy hunger but as a way to drift off to sleep. While this isn’t necessarily a problem, it can become challenging when it leads to frequent night wakings, short naps, or a mom who feels completely drained.
If you’re looking to change this habit, the key is to help your baby learn to fall asleep in a new way. You can do this using one of two approaches:
The Quick Method: A Faster Transition
For parents who prefer a faster approach—especially if their baby is six months or older—this method involves making a firm decision to stop comfort nursing and helping your baby adjust quickly.
How it works:
- Decide to stop allowing suckling for comfort. Set a clear boundary: nursing is for feeding, not for falling asleep.
- Have another caregiver take over bedtime. If possible, let your partner or another trusted caregiver handle putting your baby to sleep, at least initially.
- Replace nursing with alternative soothing methods. Rocking, patting, using a stroller, offering a lovey, or playing white noise can help your baby adjust.
- Stay consistent. The first few nights might be difficult—your baby may protest, cry, or take longer to fall asleep. But with consistency, they will adjust to the new routine, usually within a few days.
Tip: Try implementing this method over a long weekend or when you have support, so you’re not handling sleep disruptions alone.
Be prepared: Some babies take longer to adjust than others. If this approach feels too harsh or emotionally overwhelming, you may prefer the slower, gentler method below.
The Gentle Method: A Gradual Transition
If you prefer a more patient approach, you can slowly teach your baby to fall asleep without nursing. This method takes more time but tends to involve less crying and frustration.
How it works:
- Start by unlatching before you baby is fully asleep. When your baby is nearly asleep but still drowsy, gently remove the nipple from their mouth.
- Encourage a closed-mouth reflex. Lightly press on their chin to keep their mouth closed, which helps prevent them from rooting for the nipple.
- Repeat as needed. If your baby fusses, offer the nipple again briefly, then try removing it once more. Keep doing this until they eventually fall asleep without suckling.
- Continue this process nightly. Over time, your baby will learn to self-soothe and fall asleep without needing to nurse.
Pros and Cons of the Gentle Method
Pros: Less abrupt for your baby, reduces crying, and promotes self-soothing gradually.
Cons: Can take days or even weeks, requires patience, and may be challenging to maintain at night when you’re exhausted.
Tip: If possible, have a partner or family member support you at night, even if it’s just to remind you to stay consistent.
Bonus Benefit: Better Night Sleep
Once your baby no longer depends on nursing to fall asleep, you may notice a positive side effect—they wake up less often at night! Many babies who break the feeding-sleep association learn to link sleep cycles better, leading to longer, more restful stretches.
That said, if comfort nursing is working for you and your baby, there’s nothing wrong with continuing. Every baby and parent has different needs, and there’s no one-size-fits-all approach to sleep.
Final Thoughts
Transitioning away from comfort nursing can be an emotional process for both mom and baby. Whether you choose a quick or gradual approach, the key is to be consistent and choose what feels right for your family.
And remember—this phase won’t last forever. One day, your baby will fall asleep without the breast, and you may even miss those quiet, close moments.
I wish you good luck!
Paula
Moms, have you experienced being a human pacifier? How did you handle it? Share your experience in the comments below!
More About Comfort Nursing
Paula Dennholt founded Easy Baby Life in 2006 and has been a passionate parenting and pregnancy writer since then. Her parenting approach and writing are based on studies in cognitive-behavioral models and therapy for children and her experience as a mother and stepmother. Life as a parent has convinced her of how crucial it is to put relationships before rules. She strongly believes in positive parenting and a science-based approach.
Paula cooperates with a team of pediatricians who assist in reviewing and writing articles.
Trending Products
